| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 1st | Charlie | Bertrand | Merrimack |
| Attack | 1st | Jake | Gilmour | Saint Leo |
| Attack | 1st | Justin | Kesselring | LeMoyne |
| Midfield | 1st | Eric | Dickinson | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Midfield | 1st | Dan | Entenmann | LeMoyne |
| Midfield | 1st | Michael | Osmundsen | Adelphi |
| Midfield | 1st | Zack | Rusch | Seton Hill |
| Defense | 1st | James | Bassett | Merrimack |
| Defense | 1st | Zac | Prattson | LeMoyne |
| Defense | 1st | Greg | Weyl | Mercyhurst |
| SSDM | 1st | Hunter | Schmell | Merrimack |
| LSM | 1st | Collin | Lett | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| FaceOff | 1st | Blake | Boudreau | Merrimack |
| Goalie | 1st | Will | Urban | Mount Olive |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 2nd | Ben | Corrigan | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Attack | 2nd | Andrew | Kew | Tampa |
| Attack | 2nd | Jack | Moran | Seton Hill |
| Attack | 2nd | Lucas | Shafer | Lake Erie |
| Midfield | 2nd | Anthony | Busconi | St. Anselm |
| Midfield | 2nd | Ryan | MacSpadyen | Mercy College |
| Midfield | 2nd | Jake | Mosher McGraw | Tampa |
| Midfield | 2nd | Jack | Trask | Merrimack |
| Defense | 2nd | Anthony | Cesario | Belmont Abbey |
| Defense | 2nd | Brendan | Entenmann | LeMoyne |
| Defense | 2nd | Reed | Hnidy | Lake Erie |
| Defense | 2nd | Luke | Posner | Tampa |
| SSDM | 2nd | Andrew | French | LeMoyne |
| LSM | 2nd | Ian | Prate | NYIT |
| FaceOff | 2nd | Ross | Dickerson | Tampa |
| Goalie | 2nd | Thomas | Tatarian | Saint Leo |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | 3rd | LeRoy | Halftown | NYIT |
| Attack | 3rd | Nicolas | Racalbuto | Adelphi |
| Attack | 3rd | Adam | Wiedemann | Belmont Abbey |
| Midfield | 3rd | Thatcher | Clark | Mount Olive |
| Midfield | 3rd | Conor | Gronbach | Wingate |
| Midfield | 3rd | Tyler | Papa | Limestone |
| Midfield | 3rd | Andrew | Zito | NYIT |
| Defense | 3rd | Drew | Bourdeau | Saint Anselm |
| Defense | 3rd | Joe | Cillo | Seton Hill |
| Defense | 3rd | Cole | Groebner | Mount Olive |
| SSDM | 3rd | Brady | Elbin | Mount Olive |
| LSM | 3rd | Brett | Craig | Seton Hill |
| Faceoff | 3rd | Mark | Andrejack | Adelphi |
| Faceoff | 3rd | Dryden | Brous | Lynn |
| Goalie | 3rd | Max | Eismann | Seton Hill |
| Goalie | 3rd | Liam | Guiton | College of St. Rose |
| Goalie | 3rd | Brendan | McDougal | Adelphi |
| Position | Team | First | Last | School |
| Attack | HM | Jacob | Ball | Mount Olive |
| Attack | HM | Sean | Black | Merrimack |
| Attack | HM | Joe | Buduo | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Attack | HM | Liam | Osborne | Belmont Abbey |
| Midfield | HM | Jack | Griffin | Colorado Mesa |
| Midfield | HM | Kyle | McGinley | Belmont Abbey |
| Midfield | HM | Logan | Sweeney | Florida Institute of Technology |
| Midfield | HM | Clarke | Walter | Limestone |
| Defense | HM | Jake | Bye | Saint Leo |
| Defense | HM | Tyler | Gaulton | Limestone |
| Defense | HM | Maxwell | Littleton | Mercy |
| Defense | HM | Justin | Napolitano | Adelphi |
| Faceoff | HM | Jay | Scerbo | Seton Hill |